The Union Public Service Commission (UPSC) - which conducts the crucial exam that determines entry into India’s elite bureaucracy - has now been asked to explore the possibility of maintaining year-wise records of the number of attempts by each candidate. And why is that important? The move could help aspirants avoid disputes over their eligibility for future examinations. The advisory to the UPSC came from the Central Information Commission (CIC) while disposing of an appeal under the Right to Information (RTI) Act. A senior CIC official said the recommendation, if accepted by the UPSC, could provide considerable relief to civil services aspirants, particularly those who need to establish the number of attempts they have already made while determining their eligibility for subsequent examinations. For instance, a general category candidate in the 21-32 age bracket can make 6 attempts. A Scheduled Caste/Scheduled Tribe category candidate in the 21-37 age bracket can make an unlimited number of attempts. It highlights the administrative and public interest significance of maintaining a systematic record of candidates’ examination histories. Although the CIC stopped short of issuing a binding direction, it has suggested that the UPSC examine whether a more structured data management mechanism could be put in place to make such information readily accessible. Need For Data The matter came up before the CIC after a candidate sought information from the UPSC under the RTI Act regarding the total number of times she had appeared in the Civil Services Examination. The UPSC, however, expressed its inability to provide the information, stating it did not maintain the specific records sought by the applicant. Instead, she was advised to consult the Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs) section on the Commission's official website. Not satisfied with the response, the applicant approached the CIC, seeking intervention and disclosure on the number of times she had attempted the examination. While adjudicating the appeal, Information Commissioner Jaya Verma Sinha observed that the RTI Act does not oblige a public authority to create or compile information that is not available in its existing records. Consequently, the UPSC could not be compelled under the Act to furnish details that it did not maintain. However, the Information Commissioner also underlined the importance of such information from both administrative and public interest perspectives, suggesting that the UPSC consider maintaining a systematic record of candidates' appearances in the examination. The issue assumes significance because the number of attempts available to a candidate is a crucial determinant of eligibility for the Civil Services Examination. Better Data Management Under the existing examination rules, candidates are allowed a prescribed number of attempts depending on their category, subject to the applicable age limit. Any uncertainty over the number of attempts already utilised can therefore create complications for aspirants, particularly those approaching the upper age limit or the end of their permissible attempts. A year-wise database could help candidates verify their examination history, resolve discrepancies, and establish their eligibility without having to depend entirely on their personal records or recollection. It could also enable the UPSC to respond more efficiently to queries relating to previous appearances. The CIC's suggestion is aimed at encouraging better record management and greater transparency in the functioning of the country's premier recruitment agency. If implemented, a secure and easily retrievable database of candidates' examination attempts could minimise avoidable grievances and provide greater certainty to lakhs of aspirants appearing for one of the country's most competitive examinations.