It underlines that the government is free to set up trusts and societies to run specialised public programmes efficiently, but the autonomous label cannot be used to step outside the rule of law. This sends a clear legal signal to dozens of registered societies, trusts, councils, and educational or research institutions that function as extended arms of the government. The Supreme Court held that legal registration as a society cannot hide deep government control. When the state holds both the purse strings and administrative power, the body remains an arm of the government. Like the NBT, these autonomous institutions are typically created through government resolutions, headed by government-appointed leadership, and run through deep administrative and financial control by Central ministries. The judgment, titled The Chairman, National Book Trust, India & Anr. v. A.R. Abdul Gaffar & Ors., was pronounced by the Supreme Court on 6 November 2026. It clarified the legal position on employment relationships and constitutional accountability in trusts and autonomous bodies functioning as extended arms of the government. Because of this judgment, none of these bodies can now use their autonomous tag or independent fee and sales receipts to block employees from seeking justice in High Courts. Whenever these institutions make decisions on hiring, promotions, or disciplinary action, they must strictly follow constitutional standards of fairness and equality. At the same time, the judgment protects the functional identity of these organisations. While their employees enjoy protection against arbitrary treatment under Fundamental Rights, they do not automatically become central government civil servants. Conversely, the judgment also draws a clear boundary. An autonomous body or private society does not become "State" under Article 12 merely because it receives occasional government grants, performs a public utility service, or is subject to ordinary regulatory laws. If the government’s role is limited to routine statutory supervision rather than deep, pervasive financial and administrative domination, the body remains outside constitutional scrutiny. Past Judgments The judgment affirmed the Delhi High Court’s findings of 2012, in which it had declared that the National Book Trust (NBT) is a "State" under Article 12 of the Constitution. The High Court had ruled that NBT is not a purely private body. Even though it is registered as an autonomous society, the government holds deep and pervasive control over its finances, policies, and management. Because of this status, NBT is bound by Fundamental Rights. Its employees can directly approach the High Court through writ petitions to challenge unfair or arbitrary service decisions. In deciding the NBT dispute, the Supreme Court leaned heavily on its landmark seven-judge bench ruling in Pradeep Kumar Biswas vs. Indian Institute of Chemical Biology. That historic judgment dealt with major scientific research bodies operating as registered societies under the Societies Registration Act, 1860. The judges reaffirmed that a society's formal registration cannot hide its true character as an instrumentality of the State. Several past Supreme Court rulings were placed before the Bench to show how courts separate genuine State arms from ordinary societies. While organisations with mere regulatory oversight stay outside Article 12, bodies built, funded, and controlled by ministries fall squarely inside it. This principle applies directly to any autonomous body set up as a registered society to run national educational networks, literary promotion bodies, scientific laboratories, or policy research councils on behalf of the government. Key Questions Can the government create a society or trust and use its autonomous registration to bypass constitutional accountability? Does an organisation cease to be "State" merely because it generates independent revenue alongside government grants? When does an autonomous society cross the threshold from a private entity to an "instrumentality of the State" under Article 12? Can an organisation refuse to be treated as "State" to block its employees from approaching High Courts under Article 226? Does declaring a trust or society to be "State" automatically convert its employees into government civil servants? These were among the key questions resolved by the Supreme Court in the judgment. An apex court bench of Justices Prashant Kumar Mishra and Augustine George Masih laid down the clear parameters to judge the true character of such bodies. The bench examined how the National Book Trust was formed and how it functions every day. It noted that the government created NBT through an executive resolution to promote books and reading across the country. The judges pointed out that the government appoints NBT's Chairman, places ministry officials on its board, and audits its accounts through the Comptroller and Auditor General (CAG). Even changing its internal rules requires government approval. Findings On Core Questions When examining whether the government can create a society or trust and use its autonomous registration to bypass constitutional accountability, the Supreme Court ruled that it cannot. Registering an organisation under the Societies Registration Act, 1860, does not place it beyond the reach of Article 12. The Apex Court observed: "The constitutional obligation under Part III of the Constitution cannot depend merely upon the form in which governmental power or functions are organised... The constitutional inquiry is therefore directed at the substance of the relationship between the body and the government, and not at the nomenclature or legal form adopted for carrying on its activities." Addressing whether an organisation ceases to be "State" merely because it generates independent revenue alongside government grants, the Bench held that it does not. Although the Trust argued that its own receipts from book sales constituted a substantial part of its income, self-generated revenue cannot be viewed in isolation from broader structural controls. The top court held: "The fact that the Trust earns revenue from its publications therefore does not, by itself, displace the pervasive governmental control disclosed by its governing framework... financial autonomy in one aspect cannot be isolated from the statutory or regulatory structure governing the body, its composition, management and governmental supervision." On when an autonomous society crosses the threshold from a private entity to an "instrumentality of the State" under Article 12, the Supreme Court evaluated whether the body is financially, functionally, and administratively dominated by the government under a control that is particular and pervasive. For NBT, this was established via its 1957 and 1962 government resolutions, appointment of the Chairman holding office "at its pleasure", ministerial presence on the Executive Committee, and CAG audits. The Bench noted: "The question in each case would be whether in the light of the cumulative facts as established, the body is financially, functionally and administratively dominated by or under the control of the government. Such control must be particular to the body in question and must be pervasive." Regarding whether an organisation can refuse to be treated as "State" to block its employees from approaching High Courts under Article 226, the Top Court ruled that it cannot. Because NBT functions as an instrumentality or alter ego of the government, it is bound by the constitutional discipline of Part III, making its administrative and service decisions fully open to judicial review via writ petitions. The Bench affirmed: "...the Full Bench vide its judgment dated 01.06.2012 concluded that the government exercised deep and pervasive control over the Trust. It held that the trust was, in substance, an instrumentality or alter ego of the government and consequently fell within the expression 'other authorities' in Article 12 of the Constitution." Finally, concerning whether declaring a trust or society to be "State" automatically converts its employees into government civil servants, the Supreme Court clarified that it does not. Qualifying as "State" under Article 12 applies solely for enforcing Fundamental Rights and does not merge the entity into a government ministry or grant its staff civil service protections under Articles 309, 310, or 311. The Court clarified: "The declaration that the Trust is 'State' under Article 12 of the Constitution does not convert the Trust into a department of the Government of India, nor does it make every employee of the Trust a civil servant or confer upon such employees all constitutional protections available to government servants under Part XIV of the Constitution." Striking A Balance The Supreme Court’s verdict strikes a vital balance between operational flexibility and constitutional accountability. Whenever the state retains deep financial and administrative control, constitutional protections follow—ensuring that public bodies remain accountable to both the courts and the people who run them.